Moloch games

Moloch game: A negative-sum, multipolar trap situation, where rational actors, each acting in their own self-interest, choose a short-term competitive strategy that collectively ruins the outcome for everyone. 

It is an interesting time to try to build a brand. In the days of agentic AI, platformification, and “performance” marketing, trying to protect and control something as vacuous as intangible value is a hard battle to sell, let alone win, and yet win it you must, if you want any hope of profit margin. 

Agentic commerce promises decision-fatigued customers the tantalising promise of a friction-free shopping experience. You don’t even have to think about what you want for dinner, let alone do the mental arithmetic of what you need to buy to make that meal, or which brands will allow you to maximise the quality and minimise cost of each plate to fit your budget and preferences. Pixie (the Sixty60 shopping bot) or Penny (“her” Pick n Pay rival) can simply debate and decide for you. All you have to do is hand over your credit card and wait for the doorbell to ring. What is more, as trend doyenne Faith Popcorn points out, you can set your agentic friends to simply ignore any brand or item that does not fit your protein goals, calorie budget, climate and diversity, equity, and inclusion sensibilities. Don’t offer enough protein per portion to help you hit your daily target? Don’t have a 50% female board? Is it 1% more expensive than your nearest substitute? Your brand simply does not show up for consideration. Your pretty packaging and fancy focus-group perfected promotional banners don’t even enter the chat. Your customer is not tempted by a snack aisle they never stand in. Your shopper is never persuaded by the clever copy designed to override their calorie concerns with a smart argument if they never encounter the box. The end result is not unlike being an honest 5 foot 4 “short king” trying to find a date on Tinder. His profile never shows up to a woman whose preference settings have disqualified him from the get-go. The question for brands then becomes, who is filtering you out before they have even seen you? 

 

The price filter alone deserves a closer look. If shoppers are asking their agents to filter for best price, bots are not so easily moved by emotive branding elements designed to persuade fickle flesh and blood humans to give you a chance. No, unless your customer asks for you by name, an agentic assistant will choose the cheaper house (un)brand over your carefully created brand every time. In a perfectly “fair” market based on price and quality, the commodity wins over the brand every time. Such perfectly fair markets, of course, are also, as economists will tell you, zero profit markets. The very notion of which brands were meant to override. 

 

Which brings us back to the crux: the only way out of the downward spiral of the perfectly sanitised agentic shopping list is to get your customers to consciously override their own agentic assistants that have been specifically programmed to look out for their own best interests and alleviate that horrendous modern burden of thoughtful choice! And the only way to do that is to invest in building an actual brand. And that means being patient enough to spend real money on the long-term uncertain project of real, deep, brand building – at a time when margins are razor thin, investors are impatient and pay-as-you-go “performance” marketing promises you immediate demonstrable return on investment that slow burn deep relationship and trust building just cannot compete with.  

Which brands are brave enough to swim against that tide? What marketing and brand managers have the mandate (let alone the budget) to spend on seeding a field with the hope of a future harvest seasons later?  

All the incentives point to most brands falling into the neat Moloch game trap laid by the tech companies and platforms they have come to depend on. The trap that gets brands and businesses addicted to the dopamine hit of views and reach and “certainty”. To placate CFOs and shareholders that every one of their rands and cents has a provable return, but makes them ever more dependent on the platforms, and their demands for more and more share of the profits in the process (all the while starving brands of the investment needed to build a brand that can survive without the machine in the process).  

Playing by the rules of the agentic economy means sacrificing the essential value of a real relationship that is intrinsic brand value for short-term competitive metrics because everyone else is, and if you don’t play along, your funding will disappear.

The question then becomes, is your brand brave enough to defend the fragile idea of a brand in the face of all this? Or are you happy with diminishing returns? The good news is, those few who are prepared to defend the abstract, the illegible, the indefensible, the idea of intangible value will be the last ones standing once software has finished eating the profits of the legible digital supply chain. 

 

 

Share the Post:

Sign up for our Newsletter

Enjoying our blog? Get the content delivered to your inbox a few times a year to keep you up to date on thought leadership from our team.

Discover more:

Featured on Pick an Agency